Hi Spozzie,
I'm truly happy that you've read my tome-like posts! I hope that I can give reasonably short and well-reasoned answers to your questions.
Please feel free to make this a discussion, if you don't mind that my answers usually come as quickly as glaciers move.
spozzie wrote:I do have a couple of question if you would be kind enough to respond:
1) I notice that Dedication's alternative interpretation of your dream was posted on 26 November 2004 and there has been no response to it that I can see. I'm just wondering what you thought of it.
I'm happy to respond.
Initially, I think it would be a good idea to explain why I haven't responded to Dedication before I answer your direct question #1. (BTW I did PM her to let her know that I appreciated her input and would eventually respond.)
Since I've come across this web site and the materials that I've been studying and evaluating
from the site--my life has gone in a direction that I could not have envisioned. I believe the dream has laid out a directive for my life at this time, and I'm treating that fact as priority #1 in the list of things that I must attend to each day.
You will recall that in the dream I am an investigative journalist or reporter. My mission in the dream was to show the 'protective suit' to the experts that I could find. The dream fits exactly what I was doing approximately 1-1/2 years to 2 years ago. God had, I believe, led me to
Eugene's thesis of prophetic interpretation (the 'protective suit'). I studied it for many months (and continue to do so). If I'm a 'reporter' and I have a compelling 'story,' I need to have that 'story' read by others and critiqued. That is what I've been doing, as follows.
I have been studying, monthly,
Eugene's "The Ends of Time"--the Daniel segment, at this time--with a group from my local SDA church. We have gone over every word in the document. The handpicked, highly diverse group contains elders, a pastor (who is a PhD), and several lay people from that particular church. This is my mandated 'group of experts' that I understood the dream to be stating. The response has been amazingly positive thus far, but it is incredibly time consuming for me. I spend many hours per week in preparation.
I also am teaching a once per week, verse-by-verse study of the book of Revelation with two friends (we started with Daniel). They are unchurched. We have compared a historicist-based study of Daniel (the 'standard' SDA interpretations)--because that is what we did for over a year in our studies--with
Eugene's alternative paradigm. (BTW, the results are in Eugene's favor, with both groups.) This Revelation study is a tied-for-#1 priority, and to support the study I'm trying to put time into
this thread, as well as much personal Bible study.
There are too many things to list that are important and take up all of my time, but I guess the direct answer is that I'm spread too thin, time-wise. Believe it or not, answering Dedication's interpretation is pretty high on my list of things to be done. Having said that, I'll bet I won't be able to get to it for 6 months--no joking. There are at least 3 other posts that I feel are high-priority to respond to also.
Another reason that I haven't responded yet, is that God reveals His will and truth progressively (I'll bet you agree with that statement). I want to make sure that I've had enough time to pray about, contemplate on, and ask God's will regarding what she had to say, as well as an appropriate response to her. I want to make sure that the response I give her is truth, as well as I can discern it to be.
A direct answer to your question #1:
A very short answer is this: I truly appreciate that she took the time to offer an alternate interpretation. Having said that, I believe her interpretations of the symbols don't fit the symbols given in the dream, or their context. I understand the context very well. I have prayed much for light in interpreting the dream. I believe I received it. I'll deal with each point of her interpretation in my response. (I hope I don't tax your patience too much...)
spozzie wrote:2) I'm wondering why a God-given dream is not easier to interpret than it seems to be. Surely if your dream is so important to understand, God would explain its meaning to you as well? Why is it necessary to "guess" the interpretation of the dream by calling for ideas from others? Is this the normal way that God would reveal something to a person?
This is very new ground for me, Spozzie. I'm just a regular guy. If you had a dream that you--in your deepest soul--KNEW was an important message/revelation from God, how would you respond to it (especially when it is confirmed by another person's dream, through the Lord)? I prayed and wrestled and prayed some more. I asked for the prayers of others. They prayed. When I asked for folks on this Forum to comment, it is because I knew that many folks on the site have read, or are familiar, with
Eugene's prophetic thesis. I knew in my gut that the dream was in response to the struggles that I was having regarding SDA prophetic interpretation, so I wanted to see if anyone here could bring Wisdom to the table.
I also believe in the power of the Spirit within God's church--even one 'without walls.' This Forum tends to attract a fairly small number of people, but those that do stick around tend to be folks that gravitate to the 'deep things' of God. By that, I mean that they aren't afraid to get into the details of Scripture, etc. I believe there are folks here that are truly spiritual. That is an important resource.
You stated that you are wondering why a God-given dream isn't easier to interpret. I understand your sentiment completely! I guess that I'd have to wonder back: why does God ever use dreams and symbols in dreams at all? (I'm being 0% facetious here...) He could make things far easier by just appearing plainly and speaking plainly--IMHO. (We'd still find a way to get confused and mess it up, though...) But God
has chosen to communicate to people throughout history through symbolic dreams. I believe in His purpose in this choice. To wit: I asked this Forum for the light that they had to offer; they responded. We are studying this dream with our monthly study group; they offered very significant input. (It took us over 4 hours to go over 1/2 of the dream!) I asked God for light; He directed me to many sources. I believe this is the way God's church should work, and I'll bet it's the way that the Apostolic church worked after Jesus ascended to heaven--that is, if the Spirit didn't respond tangibly in a particular instance. Each member of the Body has been given a spiritual gift, for the edification of it. In summary--I believe that God wants us to
do everything in our power to understand His will for us. In my experience with this dream, I have struggled more with God than I ever have to seek His purpose in giving the dream. It has been an
incredibly rich, powerful and meaningful spiritual experience.
A last point: by no means was I trying to "guess" the meaning of the dream by calling on Forum folks to add their input. My personal belief is that God gives dreams to those that either: a) have spiritual discernment to understand the dream (e.g. Daniel); b) have access to people with spiritual discernment (e.g. Nebuchadnezzar); c) have both a and b; or d) to provide a message to someone in the future who possesses a, b, or c. (There could be other scenarios, I suppose.) I believe in this case that I fall into category 'c'. In "uncle Bob's" dream, he didn't discern the meaning of the cylinder. In my dream, I understood instantly. When Forum folks added their input, I brought it repeatedly before the Lord, and I believe He gave me the discernment to know what was accurately noted and what was truly a guess on their part. A good example would be "Nomark's" (Restin's) recollection that the dream paralled the Great Controversy in one scene. I instantly knew that she had hit upon something significant to the interpretation. I had read the Great Controversy several times, but had completely forgotten that scene while pouring my effort into understanding the dream.
Do you see the difference?
An aside:God has something in mind regarding
Eugene's thesis of multiple prophetic scenarios. This is the sole subject of our handpicked monthly study group... Since the study has begun I have had several dreams directly related to the study itself and/or the study group. The night after Bob left for Missouri after our talk, he had another dream which he wrote up and sent to me. I will probably start a "Dream Repository" thread to add these additional dreams to, and for others to add theirs.
Another aside:One of these days I'll update the dream interpretation to current understanding. I've spent time gathering supporting evidence for several items, etc.
Spozzie, I hope I've satisfied your questions a bit. If you still have questions or comments, please let me know. Thanks!
God bless, all--
Steve